EV Research & Rankings

Is EV Insurance Really More Expensive in 2026? What the Data Reveals and How to Save

Electric vehicles can cost more to insure, but the difference is not as simple as many headlines suggest. SureEV examines the latest 2026 insurance research and identifies what drivers can do to make more informed coverage decisions.

Listen to This Page
EVIE Voice · Nova

Electric vehicles offer a different ownership experience from gasoline-powered cars. Charging costs, maintenance requirements, battery technology, and driving characteristics all influence the ownership equation. But insurance is one expense that can surprise EV buyers. Are electric vehicles really more expensive to insure? If so, by how much? And can drivers reduce their premiums without sacrificing important coverage? To answer those questions, SureEV reviewed published 2026 insurance research from Insurify, MoneyGeek, and Jerry, alongside consumer guidance from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners. The findings reveal an important distinction: EV insurance can cost more on average, but the size of the difference depends heavily on which vehicles, drivers, and policies are being compared. The central finding: Comparing a newer electric vehicle with an older gasoline vehicle can exaggerate the apparent EV insurance premium difference.

Key findings

Insurify reports an average annual full-coverage EV premium of $3,159 in its 2026 analysis.

Its comparable gasoline-vehicle average is $2,218, a difference of $941 annually, or approximately 42%.

When Insurify compares vehicles from model year 2024 or newer, the reported premium difference falls to approximately 18%, or $501 annually.

MoneyGeek reports a different EV full-coverage average of $3,281 annually, reflecting its own driver and policy assumptions.

Jerry reports declining average EV insurance quotes among its customers between 2024 and the first five months of 2026, although its quoted premium levels differ substantially from other studies.

Vehicle model, location, coverage selections, repair costs, driving history, and insurer pricing can matter more to an individual driver than the national average.

Important: The studies cited here do not use identical driver profiles, insurance limits, vehicle samples, or data-collection methods. Their averages must not be combined into a single national rate.

How much does EV insurance cost in 2026?

Two major published analyses offer useful national reference points.

Research providerReported annual EV full-coverage averageMonthly equivalent
Insurify$3,159$263.25
MoneyGeek$3,281$273.42

Sources: Insurify, June 2, 2026; MoneyGeek, 2026 EV insurance analysis. Monthly figures are calculated by SureEV as annual averages divided by 12. These are separate studies, not a combined market average.

The two published estimates differ by $122 annually.

That relatively modest difference may suggest that EV insurance often represents a meaningful ownership expense, but it does not establish a universal premium for any particular driver.

Each research provider uses its own data and assumptions.

For example, MoneyGeek describes a standardized 40-year-old driver with a clean record, good credit, 100/300/100 liability coverage, and $500 comprehensive and collision deductibles.

Insurify uses its own quoted-rate database and different coverage specifications.

A driver comparing the two figures should not assume that both represent identical insurance policies.

The 42% EV insurance premium gap deserves a closer look

One of the most important findings in the 2026 research comes from Insurify.

Across the vehicle model years included in its analysis, the company reports:

Vehicle categoryAverage annual full-coverage premium
Battery-electric vehicles$3,159
Gas-powered vehicles$2,218
Difference$941

SureEV calculation

$941 divided by $2,218 equals approximately 42.4%. That supports the widely reported conclusion that EVs cost roughly 42% more to insure in this particular dataset.

However, there is a major complication.

The gasoline-vehicle sample includes older vehicles, while the EV population tends to contain newer models.

Older vehicles may have lower replacement values and different coverage needs.

Comparing a relatively new electric SUV with an older gasoline sedan does not isolate the cost of the electric powertrain.

What happens when newer vehicles are compared?

Insurify also examined newer vehicles, including model years 2024, 2025, and 2026.

In that comparison, the average EV insurance premium gap falls to approximately 18%, or $501 annually.

This does not prove that electric powertrains independently cause an 18% premium increase.

The vehicles may still differ in purchase price, performance, repair costs, safety equipment, and other characteristics.

But it demonstrates why model year matters when interpreting insurance statistics.

SureEV's interpretation: The widely cited EV insurance premium gap is partly influenced by the vehicles selected for comparison. A more useful personal comparison starts with vehicles of similar age, size, value, and coverage requirements.

Why different EV insurance studies report different numbers

Insurance research can produce different results even when every provider uses legitimate data.

Consider three major differences.

1. Different drivers

Insurance premiums depend on factors such as driving history, location, annual mileage, vehicle use, and other characteristics permitted under applicable state law.

An average based on one provider's customers may differ substantially from a standardized sample.

2. Different insurance coverage

Full coverage is an informal term, not one universally standardized policy.

Liability limits, collision deductibles, comprehensive deductibles, optional endorsements, and state-specific requirements can vary.

A lower quoted premium may reflect less protection rather than a better price for equivalent coverage.

3. Different vehicles

A study dominated by expensive performance EVs may produce a higher average than one containing more affordable compact electric vehicles.

Vehicle model and model year are critical variables.

Jerry's 2026 research illustrates these differences particularly clearly.

Its average monthly full-coverage EV quote among participating customers declined from $647 in 2024 to $548 during January through May 2026.

Those figures are materially higher than the national averages published by Insurify and MoneyGeek.

They should not be interpreted as contradictory measurements of the same standardized policy.

Jerry measures quotes generated for its customer population, not a universal national premium.

Why some electric vehicles cost more to insure

The National Association of Insurance Commissioners identifies several EV-related characteristics that may influence premiums.

Vehicle replacement value

A vehicle with a higher insured value may be more expensive to replace after a total loss.

This applies to gasoline and electric vehicles alike.

Specialized repair requirements

Some electric vehicles require technicians trained to work with high-voltage systems and specialized components.

Repair-shop availability can vary by vehicle brand and geographic area.

Battery-related repairs

Battery systems are expensive components, and damage involving the battery enclosure or associated systems can complicate repairs.

However, not every EV collision involves battery damage, and battery replacement should not be assumed to be necessary after a routine accident.

Parts and labor

Replacement parts, sensor calibration, structural repairs, and specialized labor can influence repair bills.

Many newer gasoline vehicles also have expensive cameras, sensors, and driver-assistance systems.

This is another reason to compare vehicles of similar age and technology.

Individual insurer experience

Insurers use their own claims experience, underwriting criteria, and approved rating methods.

Two companies can assign different premiums to the same driver and EV.

That is why a national insurance average cannot identify the cheapest insurer for a particular person.

SureEV analysis: What insurance savings actually mean

A lower premium can make a meaningful difference to the annual cost of EV ownership.

Consider three hypothetical situations.

These are mathematical illustrations created by SureEV, not actual insurance quotes or predictions.

ExampleOriginal annual premiumNew annual premiumAnnual savings
Comparing insurers$3,200$2,800$400
Qualifying for discounts$2,900$2,700$200
Changing deductible or coverage selections$3,000$2,760$240

The first example represents a 12.5% reduction in annual premium.

The second represents approximately 6.9%.

The third represents an 8% reduction, but changes to deductibles or coverage may increase the driver's financial exposure after a claim.

These examples demonstrate how to calculate savings. They do not establish that any particular driver will qualify for these reductions.

The five-year insurance difference

A $400 annual premium difference amounts to $2,000 over five years if the difference remains unchanged.

A $600 annual difference amounts to $3,000 over five years under the same assumption.

Actual premiums may change at renewal because of rate filings, driving history, claims, vehicle value, coverage, or other factors.

SureEV's conclusion: Comparing insurance before choosing an EV can be valuable because even a moderate annual difference may become significant over a multiyear ownership period.

Seven practical ways to look for lower EV insurance premiums

1. Compare quotes for the exact vehicle

Get insurance estimates using the actual make, model, year, trim, and, where available, VIN.

Do not assume two EVs from the same manufacturer cost the same to insure.

2. Compare identical coverage

Use the same liability limits, deductibles, drivers, and optional protections when comparing insurers.

Otherwise, the cheapest quote may simply offer less coverage.

3. Check available discounts

Ask about multi-policy, multi-vehicle, safe-driver, low-mileage, anti-theft, and other eligible discounts.

Some insurers may offer EV-specific discounts, but availability varies by state and company.

4. Review deductible options

A higher comprehensive or collision deductible may reduce premiums.

However, it also increases the amount the policyholder must pay after a covered claim.

Choose a deductible that fits your financial circumstances.

5. Consider usage-based insurance

Some insurers offer programs that evaluate mileage or driving behavior.

These programs may provide savings for eligible drivers, but the financial effect and privacy implications vary.

Review how information is collected, used, and retained before enrolling.

6. Compare insurance before buying an EV

Insurance estimates should be part of the vehicle-shopping process, alongside purchase price, charging costs, depreciation, and maintenance.

A vehicle with a lower purchase price is not automatically the cheapest to insure.

7. Review quotes periodically

Insurance pricing changes over time.

Comparing equivalent coverage at renewal can help identify whether other options are available.

Do not cancel an existing policy before replacement coverage is effective.

Is the cheapest insurance policy always the best?

No.

Price is important, but it is not the only consideration.

A policy should be evaluated based on the coverage it provides, the deductible, exclusions, insurer service, and the driver's individual needs.

EV owners may also want to review how their policy addresses vehicle damage, charging-related incidents, roadside assistance, rental transportation, and aftermarket charging equipment.

Coverage for these situations is not uniform.

For example, a home charging station may raise questions involving homeowners insurance, auto insurance, or equipment warranties, depending on the circumstances.

Drivers should confirm the applicable coverage directly with their insurer or a licensed insurance professional.

What about the cheapest states for EV insurance?

Location has a substantial influence on insurance pricing.

However, a defensible state-by-state ranking requires comparable coverage, driver profiles, vehicle samples, and sufficient observations across every jurisdiction.

Published studies do not always satisfy all those conditions.

For example, Insurify's 2026 state-level analysis excludes several states because of lower quoting volume.

For this reason, SureEV is not assigning its own cheapest-to-most-expensive rankings to all 50 states and Washington, D.C. in this report.

A state average should also not be confused with a personal quote.

An individual driver in a relatively expensive state may receive a lower premium than another driver in a state with a lower reported average.

What this means for EV buyers

The insurance decision should begin before the vehicle purchase, not after it.

A practical process is to compare several EV models, obtain insurance estimates for each, evaluate expected charging costs, and review total ownership expenses.

SureEV's EV Charging Cost Calculator can help drivers estimate electricity expenses using vehicle energy consumption and local electricity-rate assumptions.

EV Charging Cost Calculator

Our research report on the cheapest states to charge an electric vehicle in 2026 provides another useful comparison.

Cheapest States to Charge an Electric Vehicle in 2026

Insurance costs require a different approach because they are personalized.

Drivers should compare actual quotes using consistent coverage requirements rather than relying on national averages alone.

Compare EV insurance options through SureEV to explore available insurance comparison opportunities.

Compare EV Insurance

Methodology: How SureEV conducted this analysis

This article is an original SureEV editorial analysis of independently published insurance research.

SureEV did not obtain proprietary insurer rating filings, conduct a nationwide insurance quote survey, or calculate a representative national premium from raw policy records.

Sources reviewed

Insurify, June 2, 2026. The EV Premium Penalty: Insuring an EV Is 42% More Expensive Than a Gas Car, but Newer Models Are Closing the Cost Gap. Used for the reported $3,159 EV average, $2,218 gasoline-vehicle average, and newer-vehicle comparison.

MoneyGeek, 2026. Electric Vehicle Insurance: Costs and Coverage in 2026. Used for the independently reported $3,281 EV full-coverage average and its published standardized driver-profile methodology.

Jerry, 2026. Electric Vehicle Insurance Premium Trends (2024 to 2026). Used to explain quoted-rate trends and why samples from different comparison platforms should not be treated as interchangeable.

National Association of Insurance Commissioners, July 24, 2026. Electric Vehicle Insurance Rates and consumer auto insurance guidance. Used for regulatory context, EV repair considerations, and general insurance-shopping principles.

Original SureEV calculations

SureEV independently calculated: the $941 annual difference between Insurify's published EV and gasoline-vehicle averages; the approximately 42.4% difference relative to the gasoline-vehicle average; monthly equivalents for the published annual premiums; the $122 difference between two separately published national averages; and the hypothetical insurance savings percentages and five-year savings examples.

All hypothetical examples are clearly identified.

Limitations

The sources have different sampling methods, vehicle populations, coverage specifications, and study periods.

Their findings are not pooled or statistically averaged.

The analysis does not establish a causal effect of EV powertrains on insurance premiums.

No state, insurer, or vehicle model is declared universally cheapest.

Individual insurance premiums require actual quotes and underwriting.

Frequently asked questions

Is electric vehicle insurance more expensive in 2026?

Several published studies show higher average premiums for EVs than for gasoline-powered vehicles. However, the difference depends on vehicle age, model, driver characteristics, and policy coverage.

How much does EV insurance cost per month?

Insurify's reported $3,159 annual average equals approximately $263 per month. MoneyGeek's separate $3,281 annual estimate equals approximately $273 per month. Neither figure is a personalized quote.

Why do EV insurance studies disagree?

They may use different vehicles, driver profiles, insurance limits, data samples, and study periods.

Does battery damage always mean an EV is totaled?

No. Repairability depends on the damage, vehicle design, manufacturer procedures, parts availability, and insurer assessment.

Can I get a discount for driving an EV?

Some insurers offer EV-specific discounts, while others provide general discounts for safe driving, bundling, mileage, or eligible vehicle features. Availability varies.

Should I compare insurance before buying an electric vehicle?

Yes. Obtaining comparable quotes for the specific vehicles under consideration can help reveal meaningful ownership-cost differences.

Is the cheapest quote necessarily the best?

No. Drivers should compare coverage limits, deductibles, exclusions, and insurer service, not premium alone.

The bottom line

Electric vehicle insurance can be more expensive on average, but broad national comparisons do not tell the whole story.

The 2026 research suggests that comparing newer vehicles produces a substantially smaller EV insurance premium gap than comparing vehicles of all ages.

For individual drivers, the more useful question is not whether EV insurance is universally expensive.

It is whether the specific vehicle can be insured at a competitive price with appropriate coverage.

The smartest way to evaluate EV insurance is to compare equivalent coverage for the vehicle you actually drive or plan to buy.

Compare EV Insurance

Sources and references

Insurify, June 2, 2026. The EV Premium Penalty: Insuring an EV Is 42% More Expensive Than a Gas Car, but Newer Models Are Closing the Cost Gap.

insurify.com/car-insurance/report/electric-vehicle-insurance-costs/

MoneyGeek, 2026. Electric Vehicle Insurance: Costs and Coverage in 2026.

moneygeek.com/insurance/auto/insuring-an-electric-vehicle/

Jerry, 2026. Electric Vehicle Insurance Premium Trends (2024 to 2026).

jerry.ai/car-insurance/electric-vehicle-insurance-premium-trends/

National Association of Insurance Commissioners, July 24, 2026. Electric Vehicle Insurance Rates.

content.naic.org/insurance-topics/electric-vehicle-insurance-rates

NAIC Consumer Auto Insurance Guide.

content.naic.org/consumer/auto-insurance.htm

These sources are cited for specific published findings and regulatory guidance. SureEV is responsible for the original editorial interpretation and explicitly labeled arithmetic examples.

ImportantInsurance coverage, availability, and terms vary by insurer, policy, and state. This article is for general educational purposes only and is not a substitute for advice from a licensed insurance professional. Always review your policy documents and consult a licensed agent with questions about your specific coverage.

SureEV Editorial Team

Last updated: October 23, 2026

Learn more about Our Editorial Standards.

Compare EV insurance options

Compare Now